In the video “Do You Need An Expensive Fly Reel? (Fly Fishing)” by TheSlideinn, the speaker explores the concept of expensive fly reels, specifically in the context of trout fishing. They highlight that while some expensive fly reels can also be used for saltwater fishing, the primary focus is on their application for trout fishing. The video emphasizes that reels are generally not as expensive as fly rods, and the speaker goes on to discuss the basics of reels, including how to match them with price and personal preferences. They also delve into the importance of reel balance and weight. The video dismisses the significance of backing capacity and reviews various reels at different price points, highlighting the Lamson liquid reel as the best value due to it being American-made and including two extra spools. Throughout the content, the speaker shares insights on different types of fishing reels, their features, and prices, also addressing advancements in reel technology and the differences between American-made reels and their higher costs. Ultimately, they conclude that higher-priced reels often provide better quality and durability.
Understanding Fly Reels
Table of Contents
Fly fishing reels play a crucial role in any angler’s gear. They not only hold the fly line and backing but also help in maintaining balance while casting and reeling in fish. Understanding the basics of fly reels, their features, and advancements in reel technology is essential in choosing the right reel for your fishing needs.
The basics of fly reels
A fly reel is a cylindrical spool with a handle that rotates to retrieve or release the fly line. It is typically mounted on the rod’s reel seat and is responsible for creating tension on the line during casting and retrieving. Unlike conventional reels used in other types of fishing, fly reels do not have a drag system to control the line’s tension.
Reel features and importance
When choosing a fly reel, several features should be considered. The reel’s size should match the weight and length of the fly rod for proper balance. The material and construction of the reel affect its durability and performance. Reels made from machined aluminum offer better strength and precision compared to those made from cast materials.
Another essential feature is the arbor size, which determines how much line can be retrieved with each revolution of the reel. Large arbor reels are popular for their quick line retrieval and reduced line memory. The type of handle, spool design, and the presence of a click pawl or disc drag system are other factors to consider based on personal preference and fishing conditions.
Advancements in reel technology
Fly reel technology has evolved over the years, with advancements in machining and material engineering. Computer Numeric Control (CNC) machining allows for precise reel design and improved durability. High-tolerance manufacturing processes ensure smooth operation and resistance to wear and tear.
Newer reel models often feature sealed drag systems that prevent water, sand, and debris from interfering with the performance. Lightweight materials like carbon fiber are used in drag systems to provide smooth and consistent resistance. These advancements have made fly reels more reliable, efficient, and versatile for different fishing applications.
Comparing Reel Prices
Fly reels are generally more affordable compared to fly rods. While high-end fly rods can cost thousands of dollars, reels tend to have a wider price range. Understanding the cost of fly reels and their relationship with fly rods can help in making informed purchasing decisions.
Cost of fly reels against fly rods
Fly reels are typically priced lower than fly rods. While a high-quality fly rod can cost around $1000 or more, a reel of similar quality can be found at a fraction of that price. This price difference is due to the complexity and materials required in rod construction compared to reel manufacturing.
Range of fly reel prices
The price range of fly reels varies based on factors like brand, construction, and features. Entry-level reels can be found for as low as $50, providing a suitable option for beginners or budget-conscious anglers. Mid-range reels offer improved quality and performance, ranging from $100 to $300. High-end reels, often made in America and featuring advanced technology, can exceed $500.
American-made reels cost
American-made fly reels are generally priced higher due to factors like labor costs, quality control, and domestic manufacturing. These reels often provide excellent craftsmanship, durability, and performance. While they may come at a higher price point, they are considered a worthy investment for serious anglers who value quality and long-term usability.
Highlighting Specific Fly Reels
Several fly reels have gained recognition for their performance, features, and value for money. Let’s take a closer look at some specific reel models across different price ranges.
Anatomy of a $45-50 reel
At the lower end of the price spectrum, we have reels like the Echo Base, which typically costs around $45 to $50. These reels are often made of cast aluminum and offer basic features, such as a click pawl drag system. While they may not have advanced technology or high-end construction, they provide a reliable option for beginners or casual anglers.
Review of Redington zero reel
The Redington Zero reel, priced at around $100, is a popular choice among anglers. This Korean-made reel features a lightweight design and a click pawl drag system. It offers a smooth drag and reliable performance for trout fishing. The Redington Zero reel is praised for its simplicity, affordability, and quality construction.
Features of Lamson liquid reel
The Lamson Liquid reel, priced at $270, offers excellent value for money. Made in the USA, this reel comes with two extra spools, making it versatile for different fishing situations. It features a sealed drag system, precise machining, and a large arbor design for quick line retrieval. The Lamson Liquid reel is recognized for its durability, performance, and affordability compared to other American-made reels.
The Hardy disc reel
The Hardy Disc reel, priced at around $375, is a high-end reel known for its exceptional craftsmanship and performance. This Korean-made reel stands out for its sturdy construction, smooth drag system, and reliable performance. With its CNC-machined aluminum frame, large arbor design, and stylish aesthetics, the Hardy Disc reel is favored by experienced anglers who value quality and durability.
Analyzing Best Value Reels
When it comes to finding the best value in fly reels, the Lamson Liquid reel package stands out. Priced at $270, this American-made reel comes with two extra spools, providing versatility at an affordable price. The Lamson Liquid reel offers high-quality construction, a sealed drag system, and a large arbor design for smooth line retrieval. The inclusion of extra spools adds to its value, making it suitable for anglers who fish in various conditions.
Other highly recommended value reels include the Redington Zero reel and the Echo Base reel. These reels offer reliable performance, durable construction, and affordability. They provide excellent options for beginners or anglers on a budget who still want a quality reel that performs well.
Reels for Different Fishing Applications
Fly reels are designed to meet the specific demands of different fishing applications. Whether you’re targeting trout in freshwater streams or battling saltwater species, choosing the right reel is crucial. Let’s explore some reel options for various fishing scenarios.
Trout fishing reels
Trout fishing reels are generally lightweight, featuring a smooth drag system. Large arbor design helps with quick line retrieval, reducing line memory and tangles. Reels like the Redington Zero and Lamson Liquid mentioned earlier are well-suited for trout fishing due to their reliable performance and affordability.
Saltwater fishing reels
Saltwater fishing reels are built to withstand harsh environments, corrosive factors, and powerful fish species. These reels often have sealed drag systems to prevent saltwater and debris from affecting performance. They are typically made of corrosion-resistant materials like machined aluminum or stainless steel. Some popular saltwater reels include the Nautilus NV-G and the Tibor Signature series.
Other fishing application reels
Fly reels are not limited to trout or saltwater fishing. They can be used in various other fishing applications, such as bass fishing, salmon fishing, or even carp fishing. The choice of reel depends on the target species, fishing location, and personal preferences. Reels with durable construction, smooth drag systems, and appropriate line capacities are essential for success in different fishing scenarios.
Understanding the Importance of Reel Balance and Weight
The balance and weight of a fly reel play a crucial role in the overall fishing experience. A properly balanced setup ensures comfortable casting, reduces muscle fatigue, and improves control over the fly line. Understanding why reel balance matters and how weight affects performance can help in finding the right reel for your needs.
Why balance matters in a reel
Balance refers to the distribution of weight between the rod and reel. When a reel is balanced with the rod, the entire setup feels more natural and comfortable in hand. Improper balance can make casting and retrieving efforts more challenging, leading to fatigue and reduced accuracy. Finding the right balance ensures smooth and controlled movements, resulting in better casting distance and accuracy.
How weight affects a reel’s performance
The weight of a fly reel affects its overall performance and feel. Heavier reels can provide better stability, smoother line pickup, and improved shock absorption during fights with larger fish. Some anglers prefer a slightly heavier reel to add weight to their casting stroke and create smoother loops.
On the other hand, lighter reels offer increased maneuverability, reduced fatigue during long fishing sessions, and improved sensitivity for detecting subtle strikes. Lighter reels are often favored by anglers who prioritize finesse in their casting and enjoy the benefits of reduced overall weight in their gear setup.
The choice between a heavier or lighter reel ultimately depends on personal preference and fishing style. Trying different reel weights and experimenting with various setups can help determine the ideal balance and weight for individual fishing needs.
Backing Capacity: Important or Not?
The importance of backing capacity in fly reels is often a subject of debate among anglers. While some dismiss its significance, others believe it can be crucial in specific situations. Understanding the context and considering the fishing conditions can help determine the relevance of backing capacity.
Why some dismiss the importance of backing capacity
Backing capacity refers to the amount of extra line, usually a thin braided material, wound onto the reel before attaching the fly line. This extra line acts as a reserve when a fish takes a significant amount of line during a fight. However, some anglers argue that backing capacity is not essential for most fishing situations.
The main reason for dismissing backing capacity is that, in day-to-day trout fishing, the majority of fish are landed within the length of the fly line itself. Anglers rarely encounter situations where a fish takes them into their backing. Therefore, having excessive backing capacity may not be necessary for typical trout fishing scenarios.
Situations where backing capacity is crucial
Although backing capacity may not be vital in regular trout fishing, there are specific situations where it becomes crucial. Fishing for powerful saltwater species, such as bonefish or tarpon, often requires long runs and high line speeds. In such scenarios, the fish’s initial run may exceed the length of the fly line, making backing capacity necessary.
Fishing in large bodies of water, such as lakes or reservoirs, where fish have ample space to run, can also benefit from additional backing capacity. Additionally, anglers targeting larger migratory fish, like salmon or steelhead, may encounter runs that demand extensive backing.
Considering the fishing conditions, target species, and personal fishing preferences can help determine whether investing in a reel with higher backing capacity is necessary.
Reel Considering Preferences and Aesthetics
When choosing a fly reel, personal preferences and aesthetics also come into play. While the primary focus should be on functionality and performance, factors like reel design, sound, fit, finish, and customizations can enhance the overall angling experience.
The allure of tall and skinny reels
Many anglers have a preference for tall and skinny reels due to their aesthetics and performance benefits. These reels have a larger diameter and narrower spool width, allowing for increased line retrieval with each turn. The large arbor design reduces line memory and provides smoother line release, enhancing casting performance and preventing tangles.
Tall and skinny reels are often seen as sleek and elegant, adding a touch of sophistication to any fly rod setup. Their visually appealing design can be a personal preference for anglers who value aesthetics and enjoy the feeling of a well-balanced, stylish reel in their hands.
The sound, fit, and finish considerations
The sound produced by a fly reel during line retrieval or when a fish runs can be another factor influencing an angler’s preference. Some anglers appreciate the classic click sound of click pawl reels, reminiscent of traditional fly fishing. Others may prefer the silent operation of modern disc drag reels, which provide a smooth and quiet performance.
Fit and finish refer to the overall quality and detail of the reel’s construction. A well-finished reel with precise machining, attention to detail, and durable materials can give anglers a sense of confidence in their gear. The feel and aesthetics of a reel can enhance the fishing experience and provide a sense of pride in owning a high-quality piece of equipment.
Desire for frills or customizations
Fly reels come in various designs, colors, and finishes, providing anglers with options to match their personal style or complement their fly rod. Some manufacturers offer customization options, allowing anglers to personalize their reels with engraved initials, unique color schemes, or custom graphics. These frills and customizations can add a personal touch and make the reel an extension of the angler’s personality on the water.
While personal preferences and aesthetics should not be the sole determining factor, considering these aspects alongside functionality and performance can lead to a satisfying and visually appealing fly fishing setup.
Durability and Longevity of Reels
Durability is a crucial factor to consider when investing in a fly reel. Reels made from quality materials and built with precision are more likely to withstand the rigors of fishing and provide years of reliable performance. Comparing the durability and longevity of more expensive and cheaper fly reels can help in making an informed decision.
The role of durability in choosing a reel
A durable fly reel can handle the demands of fishing, including exposure to water, weather elements, and occasional accidental drops. Durability ensures that the reel’s components, such as the frame, spool, handle, drag system, and bearings, can withstand the stress of casting, retrieving, and fighting fish.
Reels made from high-quality materials, such as machined aluminum, stainless steel, or carbon fiber, are generally more durable than those made from cast materials. Precise machining techniques, corrosion-resistant coatings, and sealed components contribute to a reel’s durability and ability to withstand wear and tear over time.
Longevity of more expensive vs. cheaper reels
While expensive fly reels often provide superior durability and longevity, this is not always the case. Cheaper reels can still offer decent performance and durability depending on the materials and construction. However, higher-priced reels, especially those made in America, often undergo rigorous quality control measures and use premium materials, resulting in extended lifespan and reliability.
Ultimately, the durability and longevity of a reel depend on factors such as maintenance, frequency of use, and the angler’s fishing habits. Proper cleaning, lubrication, and storage can significantly extend the lifespan of any reel, regardless of its price point.
Expensive vs. Cheaper Reels: The Conclusion
When considering expensive vs. cheaper fly reels, factors like quality, durability, and performance come into play. While cheaper reels can offer decent functionality, higher-priced reels often provide superior craftsmanship, advanced features, and better longevity. American-made reels are typically associated with higher costs due to labor expenses and domestic manufacturing.
Quality and durability of higher-priced reels
Expensive fly reels often undergo stringent quality control measures and use premium materials, resulting in superior durability and long-term performance. These reels are made with precision machining, advanced drag systems, and corrosion-resistant materials, ensuring reliability even in demanding fishing conditions. Higher-priced reels are built to withstand the test of time, making them a worthy investment for serious anglers.
Does one really need an expensive fly reel?
The necessity of an expensive fly reel depends on an angler’s fishing goals and priorities. While cheaper reels can adequately serve beginner anglers or those on a budget, experienced anglers who prioritize superior performance and long-term durability may find value in investing in more expensive options.
It’s important to assess individual fishing needs, consider factors like the target species, fishing environment, personal preferences, and budget constraints. Experienced anglers may appreciate the advanced features and quality craftsmanship of higher-priced reels, while novice anglers can explore more affordable options to determine their fishing style and preferences before making a significant investment.
Ultimately, the choice of whether to purchase an expensive fly reel boils down to personal preferences, fishing requirements, and the angler’s willingness to invest in a piece of gear that can provide exceptional performance and longevity.